
Zen Buddhism is an ancestral lineage teaching, a teaching transmitted in part by the recorded ‘meeting and speaking’ of Ch’an/Zen practitioners. These dialogues are called mondo, “questions and answers”. Mondo often seem curt, abrupt, even hostile… “Dharma combat”. The concern in the mondo is not with politesse, it is with mutual awakening. This sharp edge is Zen’s ‘family wind’, its style. Nothing extra.
The following mondo is in the spirit of our ancestral teachers and their students (who are also our teachers). It features two students of the Way, meeting and speaking:
Q: “What about the bench outside?”
A: “It’s outside.”
Q: “What about the bench inside?”
A: “It’s inside.”
Q: “What about the bench that is neither inside nor outside?”
A: “It doesn’t exist”.
Q: “Why doesn’t it exist.”
A: “Because it is empty.”
This mondo, ostensibly about a bench outside, is [provisionally speaking] really about resolving relative and absolute into emptiness. Say what? Saying more is extra…but our family wind leaks.
“Inside and outside’ are concrete realities. The outside bench is outside, the inside bench is inside. No problem here, just ‘things-as-it-is’. Our Zen ancestors said, “high is high, low is low”, “long bamboo is long, short bamboo short”. Noticing without judging. We know judgement is arbitrary: falling off a ladder, high is not better than low; parking a car, long is not better than short. For more on this, see the essay “the Mind of Comparison”. Accepting things-as-it-is is equanimity, a mind relatively free of mental and emotional suffering. Such a mind is not inherently impeded by picking and choosing. We have to pick and choose sometimes: we don’t walk into traffic, don’t put our hands into fire. Picking and choosing is a miraculous ability…being bound to it is a heinous curse.
Equanimity, the mind of not judging, is not the end of Zen practice. It is merely the marvelous view atop a hundred-foot pole. What about the bench that is neither inside nor outside? Is there such a thing…can such a thing exist? Nope, there is no such ‘thing’. Why not? Because it has lost its ‘thingness’, it is empty of thingness. Being free of ‘thingness’ is beyond accepting things-as-it-is. It is the return of all to the vast unknown ocean of things-as-it-is. A world before picking, before comparing, even before distinguishing form and color. The inexpressible and ineffable “suchness”, or “thusness” of Zen.
But what about the traffic, the fire?
Dogen Zenji said, “flowers fall, weeds spring up”. Dogen wasn’t whining, he wasn’t comparing. Flowers aren’t better than weeds. Inside and outside is our shared experience. When judgement is necessary, judge. When it isn’t, don’t. No gap between relative-absolute. This is the view jumped free of the 100-foot pole. Chogyam Trungpa put it succinctly: “The bad news is you are falling through the sky without a parachute. The good news is there is no ground.” Complete trust, total faith, in things-as-it-is…inexpressible ineffable as it is. But don’t be fooled.
Happy non-landings.